Log-in registrieren
piqd verwendet Cookies und andere Analysewerkzeuge um den Dienst bereitzustellen und um dein Website-Erlebnis zu verbessern.


Kluge Köpfe filtern für dich relevante Beiträge aus dem Netz.
Entdecke handverlesene Artikel, Videos und Audios zu deinen Themen.

Du befindest dich im Kanal:

Volk und Wirtschaft

Isabell Hoffmann
piqer: Isabell Hoffmann
Samstag, 19.03.2016

Facts or heart? Is that the question?

“I don’t trust books. They’re all facts, no heart." Stephen Colbert geniusly put this words in Georg W. Bush mouth, we all laught and thought things could not get worse. How wrong we were. In high times of populism and unprecedented disinformation campaigns however we have to stop and think again. What if, as Jill Lepore, the author of this article, states, the age of fact is over? Are we fact lovers prepared to fight back? What are our options? Here's a little pre-read:

"Then came the Internet. The era of the fact is coming to an end: the place once held by 'facts' is being taken over by 'data'." This is making for more epistemological mayhem, not least because the collection and weighing of facts require investigation, discernment, and judgment, while the collection and analysis of data are outsourced to machines. “Most knowing now is Google-knowing—knowledge acquired online,” Lynch writes in “The Internet of Us” (his title is a riff on the ballyhooed and bewildering “Internet of Things”). We now only rarely discover facts, Lynch observes; instead, we download them. Of course, we also upload them: with each click and keystroke, we hack off tiny bits of ourselves and glom them on to a data Leviathan.

“The Internet didn’t create this problem, but it is exaggerating it,” Lynch writes, and it’s an important and understated point. Blaming the Internet is shooting fish in a barrel—a barrel that is floating in the sea of history. It’s not that you don’t hit a fish; it’s that the issue is the ocean. No matter the bigness of the data, the vastness of the Web, the freeness of speech, nothing could be less well settled in the twenty-first century than whether people know what they know from faith or from facts, or whether anything, in the end, can really be said to be fully proved.

Facts or heart? Is that the question?
6 Stimmen

Möchtest du kommentieren? Dann werde jetzt Mitglied!

Kommentare 2
  1. Christoph Z
    Christoph Z · vor fast 3 Jahren

    Das Zitat ist ein Klassiker, aber stammt nicht von George W. Bush, sondern von Stephen Colbert.

    – A fellow fact lover

    1. Isabell Hoffmann
      Isabell Hoffmann · vor fast 3 Jahren

      Aber wenn ich es doch glaube ... :) Du hast recht. Habe es gleich geändert. Erinnere mich jetzt auch. Er lehnt sich dabei so sehr colberisch vor, schlug sich auf die Brust und hauchte das "hearts" fast aus. Verrückt ist aber, dass das was damals ein bisschen extrem, aber trotzdem plausibel erschien, heute - da wir täglich so viel Irres hören - dumm aber moderat erscheint. Ich auf jeden Fall habe nicht bezweifelt, dass es ein Orginal ist. Gut, dass du aufgepasst hast. Danke.